JMS Kaplan Journal by Steve Plantz
February 21, 2008
Lucinne McCauley visits her mother
Lulu often at her new home, which is complete with a gated entry, lush landscaping
and grazing miniature horses. Lulu’s daughter often finds her mom sitting in
her favorite chair – at the end of the dining room, between a piano and large
picture window.
But Lulu’s surroundings are in no
ordinary house. Lulu has Alzheimer’s disease and two years ago, her daughter
moved her to Silverado Senior Living, a residential long-term care facility in
Encinitas.
Although the decision to put a
loved one in a care facility can be difficult, McCauley’s mother has adapted
well to her new environment. She has a
favorite nurse and a group of ladies who she sits with for meals and
activities. For McCauley and Lulu,
Silverado is as close to a dream-come-true as they could hope for - under the
circumstances. That dream, however, is
coming to an end.
The High Cost of Quality Care
Not all the residents are happy to
be living at Silverado and, in fact, many have no real concept of where they
are at all. But in the spectrum of such
facilities, the Encinitas facility is at the top. And that level of care comes at a hefty
price. At around $6,000 per month, or
$72,000 per year, a life savings can disappear very quickly.
“I do
not make $72,000 a year at my job,” McCauley says.
Lulu has been living off the
proceeds of the sale of her house and other savings for the past two years. But
that money is finally running out.
McCauley has been managing her mother’s assets and trying to stretch the
money as far as possible, but with less than $99,000 left she is looking at
what else is out there for Lulu.
She is seeking out more affordable
facilities, especially places that will accept Medi-Cal patients. McCauley is concerned, though, about the
quality of care that she might find.
“That part troubles me, and I hope
to be around as much as possible because she’ll know (that she has moved),” she
says.
Lulu is still much more lucid
after two years at Silverado than her family had expected. But that means she would be aware of the move
to a new facility and any changes in comfort that could ensue.
McCauley says she is afraid of a
significant difference between facilities like Silverado and even just the next
level down in cost. At a recent support
group meeting, one of the facility’s doctors told her that there is a large gap
in quality between top-of-the-line facilities and the ones that are approved
for Medi-Cal assistance.
“My
heart just sank,” she said after hearing the doctor’s point of view.
McCauley has looked around some
and has an impression of what the lower cost options might be like.
“They’re not going to be laid out
as nice, you know, these are real comfortable and homey. Some of the other places, they’re so
hospital-looking.”
In
fact, McCauley worries that the change could accelerate her mother’s symptoms.
The Alternatives
McCauley’s fears may not be
unfounded in terms of what is available to Alzheimer’s patients who can’t
afford a place like Silverado.
To receive assistance from
Medi-Cal in paying for resident care, the facility must be approved by
Medi-Cal. These places range from what
is called “board and care” to the more expensive skilled nursing facilities.
Such facilities are more focused
on the security of the patient and availability of medical care in case of
injuries, infections or other complications.
Places like Silverado Senior Living cost much more and place a high
importance on amenities, more individualized care, and quality of life.
While many families choose to
bring a relative with Alzheimer’s into the their own home, this is not always a
viable option, especially as the disease progresses and the patient needs more
specialized medical and nursing care.
Margaret Galante is the manager
and Director of Nursing at the George G. Glenner Alzheimer’s Family Centers,
Inc. She sees many people with early
stages of the disease who are trying to learn as much as they can about
Alzheimer’s and what their options are.
The Glenner centers are mainly day
care facilities for patients with memory disorders, but Galente often helps
families find a residential facility for those whose symptoms have progressed.
Galante
likens the process of placement to that of finding the right college for a
child.
“It’s a very individualized
process,” says Galante. “You can have an
excellent facility but if it’s not a fit for the family and not a fit for the
patient, then it’s not going to work.”
She
explains that the level of care needed can vary widely.
“You could have, say, an
80-year-old lady who is comfortable in her environment and not seeking to
leave, and a facility could take her even though she has dementia.” But Galante adds that if the patient is a
six-foot ex-Marine who does not want to stay, the type of facility needed would
be much different.
Although McCauley questions
whether Medi-Cal will provide much assistance to her, Galante describes the
system as “decidedly helpful.”
Galante explains that a facility
receiving funding from Medi-Cal or Medicare would have some of their beds paid
for by the programs. She says, though,
that such programs can be very specific in their criteria and assessment of
what level of care is needed.
“You just can’t decide you want
your mom to go to a (particular) facility or you want Medi-Cal to pay for a
facility,” she says. “(Medi-Cal) may ask
you to meet criteria and each person is evaluated (for level of need).”
The Glenner facility costs about
$70 per day for eight hours of day care.
Residential facilities around San
Diego run the gamut in price but most are well under
the cost of a place like Silverado.
McCauley says that the assistance
she can receive from Medi-Cal will only amount to what her mother has saved in
social security. She says that will only
be about $800 per month and she is expecting to pay a couple thousand on top of
that for wherever she ends up moving Lulu.
Making The Move
Even with assistance, what
McCauley is most concerned about is the psychological impact of moving Lulu to
a new home.
“It’s a really scary thought,”
McCauley says. “It’s kind of ironic
because you place them somewhere where they get a lot of stimulation and they
improve a lot.”
She says that Lulu is actually
doing better at Silverado than she was at home with much less activity. Now McCauley is afraid that moving to a
nursing home will shatter what is left of her mother’s cognitive abilities.
McCauley figures that Lulu has
less than a year left at Silverado and is bracing herself and her family for
what she fears will be a traumatic change of address for her mom.
McCauley says she is learning a
lot from her mother’s situation and has taken the precaution of investing in
long-term health insurance for herself - something she recommends for everyone.
“I don’t want my kids to have to
deal with struggling to find a place, struggling for a way to pay for it,
having to use all of my assets. I want
to protect them from that.”
###
|